Today: June 18, 2024

The Impact of New Members on BRICS: Is the Alliance Crumbling?

May 18, 2024

By Jai Hamid

In 2024, BRICS underwent expansion by extending invitations to six additional countries, yet only four of them agreed to join as Argentina opted out and Saudi Arabia postponed its decision.

Tensions arose between existing and new BRICS members regarding India’s pursuit of a permanent seat on the UN Security Council, with Egypt and Ethiopia among the new members opposing the idea. Contrary to predictions, the new members did not unanimously back the candidature of India, Brazil, and South Africa for permanent membership in the UNSC.

The year 2009 marked the formation of BRICS, a closely united alliance consisting of five nations. As we progress to 2023, this bloc has expanded its membership to include new countries. In the previous year, BRICS extended invitations to six nations—Saudi Arabia, Argentina, the UAE, Egypt, Iran, and Ethiopia.

Despite Argentina declining the offer and Saudi Arabia postponing their decision, the remaining four countries have joined the alliance in 2024. This development signifies a significant shift in the composition of BRICS, reflecting a broader and more diverse representation within the group.

 Resolving Conflict with New Faces on the Team

The BRICS alliance has evolved beyond its original five members, now incorporating a diverse range of countries. This expansion has brought a fresh perspective to the group, with each member contributing their unique viewpoint to the complex landscape of geopolitical relations.

At the center of the current tensions lies India’s ambition for a permanent seat on the UN Security Council, a proposition that has sparked disagreement among the newer members of the alliance. While Brazil and South Africa support India’s aspirations, countries like Egypt and Ethiopia are also vying for a chance to secure a seat at the prestigious council, leading to a complex dynamic within the BRICS alliance.

A source spilled the beans, revealing that old BRICS members expected newbies to back India’s UNSC aspirations. But it seems the newcomers have their eyes on their own prize. An anonymous insider said:

“When new members were admitted to the BRICS grouping last year, a formula was introduced suggesting that all new members should agree to the aspirations of India, Brazil, and South Africa for becoming permanent members of the UNSC.

But some of the new members, such as Egypt and Ethiopia, are now protesting against it as they themselves are aspirants for UNSC membership, the source added.

Problems Arise Over UN Ambitions

The plot thickened in August 2023 when BRICS expanded to include Egypt, Iran, the UAE, Saudi Arabia, and Ethiopia. They were formally welcomed in January 2024.

Last year’s BRICS members hashed out that supporting India, Brazil, and South Africa’s candidature for permanent UNSC membership would be a key joining condition. But it seems some new members missed that memo.

“Now it turns out that the letter that was officially sent to them on the terms, conditions and guidelines for their accession to BRICS did not explicitly call for support for India, Brazil and South Africa. New members like Egypt and Ethiopia are saying that they are also legitimate aspirants to be UNSC members and could not agree to just support three countries.”

BRICS Official

The Johannesburg declaration in 2023 backed this stance, advocating for a “comprehensive reform of the UN, including its Security Council, to make it more democratic and representative,” emphasizing the need for greater representation of developing countries.

BRICS Summons Unity Amidst Diverse Goals

With the upcoming BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia, in October 2024, the challenge is real. The summit aims to hash out a common stance on UNSC reforms and membership expansion, with India eager to cement its place as a permanent member.

Meanwhile, at the 15th International Economic Forum in Kazan, Ali Baqeri Kani, the Iranian deputy foreign minister, underscored BRICS’s role as a crucial player in global affairs.

Will the alliance strengthen its unity, or will the new dynamics lead to a break up?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Appeal and seek assistance from His Excellency Massninga
Previous Story

Appeal and seek assistance from His Excellency Massninga

The Ethiopian American Voter’s Guide :Your Vote Could make a Difference For Ethiopia
Next Story

The Ethiopian American Voter’s Guide :Your Vote Could make a Difference For Ethiopia

Latest from Blog

State Fragility in Ethiopia: A Book Review

By Worku Aberra Over the past 50 years, Ethiopia has faced profound political changes. The restoration of Haile Selassie’s rule in 1941 marked the beginning of systemic shifts in Ethiopia, with modernization

Shambel Belayneh presents Ayzosh Addis Ababa, the latest Ethiopian music release of 2024

Shambel Belayneh presents Ayzosh Addis Ababa, the latest Ethiopian music release of 2024 የወሎ እዝ የላስታ ፋኖዎች የአሳምነው ግልገሎች ለኦሮሞ፣ ለደቡብ፣ ለአፋር፣ ለሱማሌ እና ለሁሉም ለኢትዮጵያ እናቶች መልእክት አለን እያሉ ነው።#FanoCourage#WarOnAmhara pic.twitter.com/BqebDQhD1g
Go toTop