Ethiopia Needs Long-Term National Development Plan (Part Twenty-Two, Policy Framework and Stakeholder Dynamics)

Tsegaye Tegenu, PhD
2024-07-24

In the context of a long-term national development plan, a policy framework provides the structured and coherent set of guidelines, principles, rules, tools, and processes that guide the development, implementation, evaluation, and adjustment of policies aimed at achieving the country’s long-term development goals. It is beyond the scope this article to discuss the policy framework for each of the six goals for the vision of “Creating a Post-Scarcity Economy, Thriving Middle Class, and Self-Reliant Society”. In this section I will discuss only the policy framework of the Goal 1: Transforming and Building the Economic Structure.

When discussing policy framework, it’s crucial to understand three key components. The first component involves having a well-defined vision, clear goals, specific objectives, and comprehensive strategies. This can be referred to as “detailed intended actions.” The second component is the presence of various stakeholders who have diverse interests and behaviors and are responsible for implementing and managing these intended actions. The third component is the presence of policy which operates as the intermediary between these two components. Policy offers guidance to stakeholders on how to execute and oversee the planned actions effectively, delineating both permissible and impermissible actions to ensure successful implementation and management.

What is Policy: what to do and what not to do

Policy serves as a framework that directs stakeholders on how to properly implement and manage the detailed actions, outlining what is allowed and what is not. Stakeholders include all individuals, groups, or organizations involved in or affected by the policy. Examples of Stakeholders include government agencies (responsible for policy enforcement and regulation), private sector (businesses and industries that may be regulated or incentivized by the policy), nonprofits and NGOs (organizations that may support or oppose the policy based on their missions), and public and communities.

These stakeholders have varied interests, priorities, and behaviors. Recognizing the diversity of stakeholders is crucial for effective policy implementation and management. Policy serves as a framework that directs stakeholders on how to properly implement and manage the detailed actions, outlining what is allowed and what is not.

Policy Framework for Goal 1: Transforming and Building the Economic Structure

Pillar 1: Industrial Development and Diversification

Objective 1: Increase the contribution of manufacturing and high-value industries to GDP.

• Strategy 1: Provide financial incentives such as tax breaks and grants to attract investment in manufacturing and high-value industries.

What to Do:

• Implement clear, transparent criteria for eligibility to ensure incentives reach intended businesses.
• Regularly review and adjust incentives based on industry feedback and economic performance.
• Promote incentives through targeted marketing campaigns to attract foreign and domestic investors.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid offering incentives without clear performance metrics and accountability measures.
• Do not provide incentives to industries with low potential for growth or limited economic impact.
• Avoid complex application processes that could deter potential investors.

Objective 2: Promote the development of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in diverse sectors.

• Strategy 1: Create a comprehensive SME support program that includes access to finance, mentorship, and market access.

What to Do:

• Establish partnerships with financial institutions to offer favorable loan terms for SMEs.
• Develop mentorship networks connecting experienced entrepreneurs with SME owners.
• Facilitate access to domestic and international markets through trade fairs and online platforms.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid bureaucratic procedures that hinder SMEs from accessing support services.
• Do not neglect continuous feedback from SMEs to improve support programs.
• Avoid focusing support on a narrow range of sectors, limiting diversity.

• Strategy 2: Implement policies to reduce bureaucratic hurdles for SMEs, such as simplifying business registration and licensing processes.

What to Do:

• Digitize business registration and licensing processes to reduce time and costs.
• Implement a one-stop-shop for business services to streamline interactions with government agencies.
• Regularly review and revise regulations to ensure they remain relevant and efficient.

What Not to Do:

• Do not maintain outdated or redundant regulations that complicate business operations.
• Avoid ignoring stakeholder feedback when designing and implementing regulatory changes.
• Do not implement changes without proper public awareness campaigns.

Objective 3: Enhance technology adoption and innovation in industrial processes.

• Strategy 1: Promote digital literacy and advanced skills training programs to prepare the workforce for technology-driven industries.

What to Do:

• Partner with educational institutions and private sector to develop relevant training programs.
• Provide incentives for companies that invest in employee training and upskilling.
• Ensure training programs are accessible to all, including marginalized communities.

What Not to Do:

• Do not create training programs without alignment to industry needs and future trends.
• Avoid neglecting continuous evaluation and improvement of training programs.
• Do not restrict access to training programs due to high costs or limited availability.

Pillar 2: Agricultural Modernization

Objective 1: Improve agricultural productivity through the adoption of modern farming techniques.

• Strategy 1: Provide subsidies and financial incentives for the adoption of modern farming equipment and techniques.

What to Do:

• Target subsidies to farmers who demonstrate commitment to adopting new technologies.
• Collaborate with agricultural suppliers to ensure availability and affordability of modern equipment.
• Monitor and evaluate the impact of subsidies on productivity to ensure effectiveness.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid providing subsidies without ensuring proper usage and maintenance of equipment.
• Do not create complex application processes for subsidies that deter farmers.
• Avoid ignoring the diverse needs of small and large-scale farmers.

• Strategy 2: Establish agricultural extension services to educate farmers on best practices and new technologies.

What to Do:

• Recruit and train extension officers to provide hands-on support to farmers.
• Use various channels (e.g., workshops, mobile apps, radio) to disseminate information.
• Foster collaborations with research institutions to keep extension services updated with the latest innovations.

What Not to Do:

• Do not neglect continuous training and support for extension officers.
• Avoid limiting extension services to specific regions or types of crops.
• Do not rely solely on traditional methods of information dissemination.

Objective 2: Enhance value chains and market access for agricultural products.

• Strategy 1: Invest in rural infrastructure, including roads and storage facilities, to reduce post-harvest losses and improve market access.

What to Do:

• Prioritize infrastructure projects that directly impact agricultural productivity and market access.
• Engage local communities in planning and maintaining infrastructure projects.
• Ensure investments are sustainable and environmentally friendly.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid over-centralizing infrastructure investments, neglecting remote or less populated areas.
• Do not delay maintenance and repair of existing infrastructure.
• Avoid ignoring the environmental impact of infrastructure projects.

Objective 3: Increase investment in agricultural research and development.

• Strategy 1: Increase funding for agricultural research institutions and universities.

What to Do:

• Allocate consistent and sufficient funding for research initiatives.
• Encourage partnerships between research institutions, universities, and the private sector.
• Focus research efforts on addressing local agricultural challenges and opportunities.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid funding research without clear objectives and expected outcomes.
• Do not neglect the dissemination of research findings to farmers and other stakeholders.
• Avoid limiting research to traditional crops and methods.

• Strategy 2: Develop research programs focused on climate-resilient crops and sustainable farming practices.

What to Do:

• Prioritize research on crops and practices that address climate change impacts.
• Collaborate with international research organizations to share knowledge and resources.
• Involve farmers in research trials to ensure practical applicability of findings.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid focusing solely on short-term solutions without considering long-term sustainability.
• Do not ignore the importance of traditional knowledge and practices in research.
• Avoid duplicating efforts without coordinating with existing research programs.

Pillar 3: Infrastructure Development

Objective 1: Expand and upgrade transportation networks, including roads, railways, ports, and airports.

• Strategy 1: Implement a national infrastructure development plan prioritizing key economic corridors.

What to Do:

• Conduct thorough feasibility studies to identify and prioritize key economic corridors.
• Engage stakeholders, including local communities, in the planning process.
• Ensure projects are environmentally sustainable and socially inclusive.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid overloading existing infrastructure without proper upgrades and maintenance.
• Do not neglect the potential impact on local communities and environments.
• Avoid implementing projects without securing necessary funding and resources.

Objective 2: Improve access to reliable and affordable energy and water supply.

• Strategy 1: Invest in renewable energy projects to diversify the energy mix and enhance sustainability.

What to Do:

• Promote public-private partnerships to fund and develop renewable energy projects.
• Ensure regulatory frameworks support the integration of renewable energy into the grid.
• Provide incentives for businesses and households to adopt renewable energy solutions.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid relying solely on non-renewable energy sources for future energy needs.
• Do not implement renewable projects without community engagement and support.
• Avoid neglecting the maintenance and sustainability of existing energy infrastructure.

• Strategy 2: Modernize existing power grids and water supply systems to reduce losses and improve reliability.

What to Do:

• Conduct regular audits and assessments of existing infrastructure.
• Invest in smart grid technologies to enhance efficiency and reliability.
• Prioritize areas with the highest need and potential impact for upgrades.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid deferring maintenance and upgrades due to budget constraints.
• Do not implement changes without considering long-term sustainability.
• Avoid overlooking the importance of training and upskilling workforce for new technologies.

Objective 3: Develop digital infrastructure to support a knowledge-based economy.

• Strategy 1: Expand broadband internet access to rural and underserved areas.

What to Do:

• Partner with telecom companies to extend broadband infrastructure to underserved regions.
• Provide subsidies or incentives to reduce costs for low-income households.
• Invest in digital literacy programs to ensure effective use of internet access.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid focusing solely on urban areas, neglecting rural needs.
• Do not implement projects without considering long-term operational sustainability.
• Avoid neglecting the quality and speed of internet access provided.

Pillar 4: Human Capital Development

Objective 1: Increase access to quality education and vocational training.

• Strategy 1: Establish partnerships with the private sector to provide vocational training and apprenticeship programs.

What to Do:

• Develop industry-relevant training curricula in collaboration with private sector partners.
• Provide incentives for companies to offer apprenticeship opportunities.
• Monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of training programs to ensure continuous improvement.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid creating training programs without alignment to industry needs.
• Do not neglect the importance of soft skills alongside technical skills.
• Avoid limiting opportunities to specific demographics or regions.

Objective 2: Improve health outcomes through better healthcare services and facilities.

• Strategy 1: Increase funding for public healthcare infrastructure and services, with a focus on underserved areas.

What to Do:

• Prioritize funding for healthcare facilities in underserved and remote areas.
• Invest in training and retaining healthcare professionals.
• Implement community health programs to address preventive care and health education.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid focusing solely on urban healthcare facilities, neglecting rural needs.
• Do not allocate funds without proper oversight and accountability measures.
• Avoid ignoring the integration of modern technologies in healthcare delivery.

Objective 3: Enhance workforce skills to meet the demands of a transforming economy.

• Strategy 1: Develop continuous professional development programs to upskill the current workforce.

What to Do:

• Partner with industries to identify skill gaps and design relevant training programs.
• Provide financial support or incentives for workers to participate in upskilling programs.
• Ensure programs are accessible and flexible to accommodate working professionals.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid offering outdated or irrelevant training programs.
• Do not restrict access to professional development opportunities based on cost.
• Avoid neglecting the evaluation and update of training programs.

• Strategy 2: Encourage industries to provide on-the-job training and career development opportunities.

What to Do:

• Incentivize companies to develop robust on-the-job training programs.
• Promote a culture of lifelong learning and continuous improvement within industries.
• Support career development initiatives that align with industry needs and employee aspirations.

What Not to Do:

• Avoid mandating training without providing adequate support and resources.
• Do not overlook the importance of mentorship and coaching in career development.
• Avoid neglecting feedback from employees on training and development needs.

Formulärets överkant

Formulärets nederkant

Understanding the interplay between detailed intended actions and stakeholder dynamics is essential in policy-making. Policies act as a guiding framework that aligns stakeholder actions with the planned strategies and objectives, ensuring effective and efficient implementation. By providing clear directives on what to do and what not to do, policies help manage the complexities of diverse stakeholder interests and behaviors, thereby facilitating the successful realization of the policy’s vision and goals.