By Seid Hassan, PhD
Seid Hassan, PhD
second commentary , which itself is a response to Professor Teshome Abebe’s commentary. For obvious reason, his response (my) has nothing to do with Professor Abebe’s commentary.
The Technical Error: While trying to show the appreciation of the real exchange rate, I used a simple and standard formula for currency appreciation (a formula used to calculate changes in percentage prices, such as inflation) instead of depreciation. In short, Professor Alemayehu’s calculation of 17.3%, regarding what I referred to as “stealth devaluation” is technically the “correct one” – per the suggested formula, instead of the 21% that I suggested. I strongly argue, however, that the reality is closer to, if not higher than, to the 21% since both my and professor Alemayehu’s calculations are static in nature and exclude compounding and the impact of expectations.
Reasons for using the formula: In my article that was disseminated on August 1, 2014, I reluctantly used the standard and simplest formula which depicts the relationship between the nominal and real exchange rates. I reluctantly used that formula partly because I happen to receive messages and complaints (beginning all the way back to 2008), largely from laypersons, who either disagree with my assertions of the overvaluation of the birr and/or do not understand how it works. As I stated in the same article, some bloggers and commentators also happen to continuously make similar mistakes. I used that simple formula hoping that presenting it would serve as a good learning moment for them and to show some others that there are some theoretical and technicalities involved behind the assertion of the appreciation of the birr’s real exchange rate.
Remittances and Foreign Aid Flows and Real Exchange Rate Appreciation: I am somewhat mystified by Professor Alemayehu’s suggestion that I have made an error on this issue. In the same article, I stated that the huge remittance and foreign aid flows contribute (and, not cause) the appreciation of the birr’s exchange rate (overvaluation of the birr.) On domestic grounds, the birr’s value has been falling due to rising costs of living and inflation rates. But, both the official and the suppressed and interfered with black market exchange rates fail to reflect this fact, thereby raising the real exchange rate. In case Professor Alemayehu or anyone else is not aware, the international economics literature is replete of remittance and foreign aid flows causing and contributing to real exchange rate appreciations and even leading to what is known as the Dutch Disease.
Here is the other point that I was making, albeit indirectly: Amusingly, both the World Bank and the authorities encourage foreign aid flows into the country, even though I and many notable experts, such as Professor William Easterly believe that a good portion of foreign aid has been misused and abused by both donors and recipient countries and has been counterproductive to aid recipient countries such as Ethiopia. When it comes to remittance flows, the over 160,000 Saudi repatriation of Ethiopians, their mistreatments and the mishandling of the issue by Ethiopian authorities reveal the existence of a policy of exporting of people and benefitting from their concomitant remittances- one of the current research topic of mine. But, as suggested above, these flows contribute to the overvaluation of the real exchange rate. Given the policy of using remittance and aid flows as promoters and growth instruments, one could easily observe devaluation measures being exercises in perpetuity (and exercises in futility.)
A Response to Tsehai Alemayehu on Devaluing The Birr
Latest from Blog

IMF Leader to Travel to Ethiopia Amidst Economic Turmoil
The Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), Kristalina Georgieva, is scheduled to visit Ethiopia on February 8 and 9 as the nation progresses with its comprehensive economic reforms. Ethiopia, home

A plea to Eskinder Nega
By Allelign Sisay I recall one of your interviews about the Judgment of Solomon (1 Kings 3:16-28). In it, you urged Ethiopians to act in the spirit of the wise king and

Unpacking BABY KING Abiy Ahmed’s Claims on Jimma Homes: Insight or Illusion?
In this article, we endeavor to unravel the narrative spun by Ethiopian Prime Minister, Abiy Ahmed, around the destruction of an estimated 15,000 homes in Jimma. His startling assertion that the affected

Why Have Jawar’s and Lidetu’s Non-Violent Movements Failed to Get Traction?
Yonas Biru, PhD Lidetu has been in Ethiopian politics for over three decades. Jawar’s political ንክኪ is a tad shorter. In total, he has a quarter of a century worth political stripes

Abiy’s Idiocy: How One Man’s Stupidity Crippled a Country
(THE HABESHA) – This article offers a comprehensive analysis on the leadership style and decisions of Abiy Ahmed, the current Prime Minister of Ethiopia. Renowned on the global stage, Abiy Ahmed has

Breaking the Chains of Tribalism
Dula Abdu Mohamud A. Ahmed (Prof.) as an individual or an organization promoting Sustainable programs through the OWS Development Fund, located in the Somali region of Ethiopia suggests that ethnic federalism

Minority Faction Negotiations Ignite Widespread Outrage Among Amharas
(The Habesha) –Controversial negotiations have been triggered between minority factions of the Amhara Fano forces and representatives from the EU, AU, USA and IGAD, sparking fierce unrest among the Ethnic Amhara community

Ethiopia Urges King Charles to Return Looted Sacred Artifacts from 150 Years Ago
By OLIVIA ALLHUSEN / Daily Mail Ethiopia has formally requested that King Charles and the British Army return artefacts deemed ‘sacred’ that were taken during a conflict 150 years ago. These significant items

The Leaders of Fano Groups at the Heart of Amhara Operations
(The Habesha) – In the vast political landscape of the Amhara Region, the role and influence of Fano groups continue to generate interest and discussion. Who leads these compelling collective forces? What

The Development Strategies of Singapore vs. Ethiopia: A Comparative Analysis of Education and Beautification
Dr. MeKonnen Birru (birrum@uhd.edu) Over the past few decades, Singapore and Ethiopia have pursued distinct paths to development. While Singapore’s transformation into a global economic powerhouse is often attributed to its focus

FANO Leader Zemene Kasie Denies Engagement in Government Negotiations
(THE HABESHA) – In the ever-shifting landscape of power struggle and negotiations, FANO Zemene Kasie stands as a steadfast bulwark, maintaining their stance of not yet engaging in dialogue with any government

Why Both Ethiopia-Centered and Tribe-Based Change Agendas Continue to Fail
Yonas Biru, PhD (unedited draft for discussion) A caveat is in order at the outset. The article focuses on Oromo, Amhara and Tigray extremist forces and their conflict-brewing sidekicks in the diaspora.

Statement on current developments by the Amhara Fano People’s Organaization (AFPO)
The Amhara Fano People’s Organization (AFPO) proudly represents the armed resistance of the Amhara people a movement born out of necessity in the face of systemic Genocide, state-sponsored violence, and deliberate political

Eskinder Nega: A Portrait of Two Faces – Freedom Fighter and Divider
Dr. MeKonnen Birru (birrum@uhd.edu) Eskinder Nega, a name synonymous with the struggle for democracy and freedom in Ethiopia, is a man of undeniable courage, but also one of stark contradictions. Known for

The Legacy of Professor Getachew Haile: A Tribute to an Extraordinary Scholar
(The Habesha) – In the world of academia, few individuals made as indelible a marked as Professor Getachew Haile. The famed scholar, celebrated for his profound researched and deep expertise, was a