These old images do not show a recent military exercise in Eritrea

Amanuel Neguede / AFP Ethiopia
Three pictures — one of trucks loaded with missiles, another of tanks and a third showing jets flying over a building — have been circulating on Facebook in Ethiopia with claims that they show a recent military exercise in Eritrea. But the claims are false: AFP found that the post uses old, unrelated images.

The photos, published in a Facebook post on October 19, 2021, have been shared nearly 300 times and drawn thousands of likes.

“Breaking news: the Eritrean Defense Forces have completed the so-called special military exercise. They are ready for everything,” the post reads in Amharic.

Screenshot of the false Facebook post, taken on October 21, 2021

It further claims that the exercise demonstrated the Eritrean Air Force’s capabilities and showed off their arsenal of “several drones, ballistic and other missiles”. The post then lauds a “spectacular exhibition of heavy artillery tanks”.

Eritrea has been at the centre of the nearly year-long conflict in Ethiopia’s northern region of Tigray. The governments of Ethiopia and Eritrea long denied any involvement of Eritrean forces in the conflict, which erupted in November 2020. But in March 2021, Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed admitted that troops from the neighbouring country were in Ethiopian territory.

Read Aloud:   Ebola-Hit Nations Aim for No New Cases- VOA
Map showing Ethiopia and Eritrea

However, the claims that the images were taken during a recent military parade in Eritrea are false.

Old military graduation event

Contacted by AFP Fact Check, Eritrea’s Information Minister Yemane Ghebremeskel dismissed the images as “false news”.

While the first image of trucks loaded with missiles does show Eritrean military equipment, Yemane confirmed that the photo was taken at a defence training centre in Sawa during the graduation ceremony of the “32nd Round of National Service” in August 2019.

Eritrean media outlet Tesfa News covered the event in an article published on August 2, 2021. The trucks seen in the Facebook post are visible one hour into a YouTube video embedded in the story.

Screenshot of the YouTube frame where the same trucks seen in the misleading Facebook post

“The vehicles shown are carrying Frog (or S-112) rockets. These were captured in the mid-1980s from the Derge’s army. These are ground to air rockets with a range of 20-25 Kms,” Yemane said.

Emirati tanks

By running a reverse image search, AFP Fact Check found the second image in an article called “Outsourcing war: How foreigners and mercenaries power UAE’s military”, published on the Middle East Eye website in 2018.

Read Aloud:   Abdu Kiar on his Mekelle music concert

According to the caption, the photograph — credited to AFP — captures a military display at the International Defence Exhibition and Conference (IDEX) in the Emirati capital, Abu Dhabi.

The picture was indeed taken by AFP photographer Karim Sahib on February 19, 2017. It shows Emirati armed forces at the opening ceremony of IDEX, not the Eritrean military.

( Nina LAMPARSKI)

Blue Angels squadron

While AFP Fact Check was unable to trace the exact image of the jets flying over a building, our search revealed another similar photograph on the Alamy stock photography agency’s website.

According to the caption, the photo shows the “Blue Angels” of the US Navy flying over Alcatraz Island in San Francisco on October 8, 2021.

Side-by-side comparison of the image from Alamy (L) and the image seen on Facebook

Although the images aren’t identical, noticeable details such as the light house on the right and the water tank on the left suggest both images were captured in the same location during the demonstration of the Blue Angels.

Read Aloud:   Ethnic nationalism on a collision course with Ethiopia more than ever

AFP Fact Check contacted the US Navy for more details about the performance and will update this fact check accordingly

2 Comments

  1. What is AFP’s point? H.E. Yemane Ghebremeskel has dismissed the images as “false news” anyway. End of story. AFP, get a job!!!

  2. Brother Isaias must start worrying now because Debre will be coming for you soon. Abiy’s story telling brass have no clue how to stop him. He has been rampaging unhindered from Mekele all the way to the gates of Dessie. After the fall of Dessie it is going to be smooth sailing all the way to Addis/Finfine, After a well deserved recess and muscling up Debre will turn his attention to north of the Mereb river. Asmara, here I come, baby!!! Brother Isaias! If I were you I will start packing up now. I will ask my homeboys in Algiers to have a flat there ready for you.
    How about you Afars. What are doing in the territory that does not belong to you. You must vacate the entire area from the banks of the Awash River all the way to Assab because it belongs to Debre. You have cousins in Djibouti, don’t you? You should move there. End of story!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

twelve − seven =