Ethiopian News | ZeHabesha | Latest News Provider

The story behind the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam

5

By FASIL LEGESSE/JP
AUGUST 23, 2020

I have read the article on the ongoing negotiation between Ethiopia, Egypt, and Sudan on the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD). There are important facts that I have to highlight first. Ethiopia is the source of the Blue Nile and contributes 86% of the water. The GERD is the first major project the country is building on this River Basin. It is the symbol of the African Renaissance. The GERD is a hydroelectric generating dam, which Ethiopia is building on its rightful and equitable share over the Nile using its own finance.

While noting the effort of the writer to bring the matter to the attention of his readers, I thought I should add my voice to bring a more balanced perspective on what transpired during the ongoing negotiation. As an Ethiopian-Israeli, I follow this very closely.

Fasil Legesse, Editor-in-Chief of Israeli-Ethiopian TV

The writer talks at length why Egypt is “justifiably’’ worried about the Dam. It is regrettable that he does not equally present the facts about Ethiopia. Ethiopia, the second-most populous nation in Africa, has suffered from consecutive severe droughts. Ethiopians faced existential challenges due to a lack of water and electricity. Millions of Ethiopians had perished due to famine. The issues of food security, water scarcity, and energy deficit are critical and daily challenges to millions of Ethiopians. This is not about the choice of comfort and luxury rather it is about basic livelihood and sustenance; it is about how to meet the day to day fundamental needs of the Ethiopian people.

The readers would like to know why the Dam is vital for Ethiopia. More than 60 million Ethiopians don’t have access to electricity and they are living under abject poverty while their country is the source of the longest river in the world. In all reasonable accounts, it is very legitimate that Ethiopia is building a dam on a river that it is endowed with to meet the urgent development needs of its growing population. For Ethiopia, the Dam is justifiably the right thing to do. If a poor country like Ethiopia does not use its resources, its very existence would, no doubt, be in question. Hence, generating electricity is necessary to reduce poverty, create jobs for its millions of youth.
On the GERD negotiation, Ethiopia has demonstrated its commitment to foster cooperation and attainment of a win-win outcome. With the launch of the project in 2011, Ethiopia invited Egypt and Sudan for consultation and initiated a series of platforms. However, progress in the negotiations is stalled due to the conducts of Egypt. Even then, Ethiopia has been dedicated to complete the negotiation on the guidelines and rules for the first filling and operation of the GERD.
From the very beginning, Ethiopia went to a great length to address the concern of Egypt and Sudan. Ethiopia is the one that commenced the dialogue acknowledging the Nile belongs to all riparian states. Ethiopia agreed to the establishment of the International Panel of Experts, then jointly created the Tripartite National Committee and the National Independent Scientific Research Group. In fact, a team of international water experts has proved that the Dam benefits not only Ethiopia but also Egypt and Sudan. And that is why the three leaders from Ethiopia, Egypt, and Sudan agreed on Principles of Declaration to cooperate on the Dam in 2015. It is the same spirit that recognized the mutual benefit of the Dam that should guide the ongoing negotiation. While contributing 86 percent of the water that goes to Egypt, it is very clear that Ethiopia has a legitimate and sovereign right to use its natural resources based on the principles of equitable and reasonable utilization of the river.
Ethiopia is a state party to the Agreement on the Nile Basin Cooperative Framework (CFA), an outcome of a thirteen years negotiation that involved Egypt. It was signed by six riparian countries including Ethiopia. The CFA as a multilaterally negotiated Framework Agreement on the Nile Basin enshrines the cardinal principles for utilization of the Nile River and establishes the Nile River Basin Commission. Ethiopia has made an extraordinary effort to accommodate Egypt’s demands and ways. The only exception is the unjustified and absolutely unacceptable proposition of “historical right and existing uses” advanced by Egypt which attempts to monopolize the river. Ethiopia, time and again stated clearly that it adheres to the principle of not causing significant harm to downstream countries.
Recently, the tripartite negotiations have been going on through video conference and the representatives of the three countries continue the internal consultations at the higher levels. For a person who follows up these negotiations closely, the parties are engaged in intense deliberations to address the remaining outstanding technical and legal issues related to GERD. Genuine dialogue is the best option that the three countries have and thus, they should be unequivocally committed to meaningful talks respecting Ethiopia’s rights to use the Nile water. I would certainly state that this is and has always been the interest and position of Ethiopia who remains committed to partnership and regional cooperation.
Unfortunately, it is Egypt that acts and behaves as if the Nile water belongs only to one country. Egypt and Sudan have a water-sharing agreement that denied Ethiopia its right to equitable share. Egypt wants to maintain its monopoly. That mentality does not help and if fact, is an obstacle for win-win solutions- solutions that could come out only through constructive dialogue that unambiguously accepts the right of all riparian states to benefit from their shared resources. The main challenge in the current negotiation is the demand to perpetuate the status quo, which is unfair.
Egypt can establish its legitimate right over the Nile by concluding a water allocation treaty within the framework of the CFA. The GERD negotiation has become prolonged and futile due to Egypt’s attempt to acquire a water allocation guarantee aligned with the unfair 1959 share under the guise of dam operation rules.
Amplifying tensions, exaggerating threats and warmongering would not lead to mutually beneficial outcomes. I believe continued dialogue with good faith and full commitment to the existing tripartite mechanism is the best option to solve legal and technical differences raised by the three countries.

The author is the Editor-in-Chief of Israeli-Ethiopian TV

5 Comments

  1. Subject: The story behind the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam, By Fasil Legesse, Editor-in-Chief of Israeli-Ethiopian TV, August 23, 2020. Published by ZeHabesha.

    Commentary, 23 August 2020
    I find the Article refreshingly understandable of its content due to its straight forward structure for readers like me, without having to struggle with bombardment of heavy words and complex sentence structure. With that comment, let me repeat what I have been writing on the subject >>>> reconciliation between Ethiopia, Egypt and Sudan.

    My ‘broken record’ opinion is simple: Egypt will never agree on any arrangement on the subject matter other than the agreement it reached with Britain, and Britain only, years and years go >>> without the presence of Ethiopia, the SOURCE of the Blue Nile!!!!!!! Let me be brutally frank. Egypt will NEVER WILLINGLY sit with Black Africans to discuss and negotiate on what it has already agreed upon with a colonial entity I.e. Britain. We are NOT talking about RATIONALITY. We are facing a glaring negative attitude of an Arab country, refusing to negotiate on the WATER that originates from Ethiopia without gaining a drop of benefit out of it, while the Arab country enjoys the benefit of one hundred percent of someone’s natural wealth!!!!!!. Good bye “fairness”!!!! It is simply ridiculous, absurd, and — under normal situation — beyond belief. Let me be CRUED: Could it happen to a WHITE Country ?!?!?!? Would Egypt dare to apply its absurdity to an European Country?!?!? NEVER! NEVER!

    Ethiopia is better off to continue, full blast, with its GERD Project, always maintaining its noble practice of considering the utilization of the “WATER” by countries where the NILE flows through. By any standard, what we have now is NOT FAIR — in fact FOOLISH — not to utilize its natural resources for fundamental needs of its people, while Egypt has the full benefit of the RESOURCES!!!!. It is a simple glaring and ugly situation where the BLACK AFRICAN PEOPLE’S LIFE amounts to NOTHING. THAT is the WHOLE point. Let us face it squarely and call a SPADE is a SPADE. THE END (in its fullest ugly sense)

  2. Thank you Fasil for the well measured and unbiased opinion that should be an exemplary to follow by Ethiopia, Sudan and Egypt. I used to live in Egypt in late 1980s and early 1990s, Egyptians firmly believe that the Nile is theirs. Egyptians do not recognise the Nile sources countries have rights to use and they are completely out of touch with reality.

  3. Thank you, Fasil, for the objective opinion you forwarded. It is so refreshing to get views from our Ethiopian Israeli brothers and sisters on the issue. Egyptian propaganda has multitude of media access and outlets and their deafening misinformation has dominated the Middle East and some corners of the world for too long.

    I guess we will never match their level, but with truth and justice on our side we have simple but strong argument to make, as you pointed out in your article. It is encouraging to see a lot is happening in this direction these days.

    Just a thought – Neither our whispers nor screams from Addis appear that audible to Cairo…But due to the proximity (Tel Aviv and Cairo), can you whisper the truth in their ears, please? (added for a smile)

  4. እነ ቱርክ እነ ሶርያን እንደሚያደርቋቸው ወይንም እነ አሜሪካ እነ ሜክሲኮን እንደሚያደርቋቸው አይነት ነገር DEVILS መሆን የለብንም:: የፈለገውን ያህል ወታደራዊ ኃይል እንኳን ቢኖረንም በጉልበቱ ተማምኖ ሌሎችን በውሃ ጥም የሚገድል ሃያል መንግስት መሆንንም መመኘት የለብንም:: ግን ደግሞ ራሳችንን የምንበድል ነገሮች እንድንሆንም ማንም አይጠብቅብን:: ለዚህ ሁሉ ቀላሉ መንገድ፣ አለም አቀፋዊ ህጎችን ማክበር ነው:: መላ የሰው ልጆችን በእኩልነት የሚያይ አለም አቀፋዊ የውሃ ህግ የሚባል ነገርም እንዳለ አንዳንዶቹ ሲያወሱ ታዝብያለሁኝ:: እሱን የመከተልና ሌሎች የአለሚቱ አካል ሃገራትም ይሄንን የሰው ልጆች ለሰው ልጆች መገልገልያ ብለው የነደፉትን ህግን የማክበር ግዴታ እንዳለባቸው ብጥሞና ማሳሰብ አለብን::
    ግን ምድሪቱ በስግብግብነት የተወጠረች እንደመሆኗ መጠንም ራሳቸውን ብቻ እንጂ ስለሌላው ግድ የሌላቸው ፍጡራንና መንግስታትም አሉና፣ እነዚህን ግን መጋተር ይኖርብናል፣ ድሮ መጥተውብን በባዶ እግራችን እሾህና ድንጋይ እግራችንን እየጎነደፈን ሃገራችንን ተከላክለን አባርረናቸዋል:: ጠላቶች የጭስ ዝናብ ያፈሰሰሱብን ጊዜ ብቻ ነበር አይናችን ስለተሸፈነና ሳንባችን ስለታፈነ መከላከል ያልቻልነው፣ ይሄንንም ቢሆን ታሪክ እንደሚያስታውሰው ጊዜ ወስደንና በየገደል ጣሻው እየተንከራተትን ተወጥተነዋል::
    ከእንዲህ ግን እንዲህ አይነት ሁናቴ እንዳይፈጠርብን ከወዲሁኑ መዘጋጀት ይኖርብናል፣ ለነገሩ ያለንን የሃብት ምጣኔ ለህዝባችን ምግብ ጤንነትና ትምህርት የመሳሰሉ የሰው ልጆች Basic የመጀመርያ አስፈላጊነት ያላቸውን ጉዳዮችን በማቅረብ የህዝባችንን ፍላጎቶችን ማሟላት ነበር ቅድሚያ ያለው ተግባራችን መሆን የነበረበት::
    ግን እነ ግብፅን የመሳሰሉ ስግብግቦች ሰላም እስከነሱን ጊዜ ድረስ ራሳችንን እስከ አፍንጫችን ድረስ ታጥቀን ሃግራችንንና ግድቦቻችንን ከመከላከል ሌላ ምርጫ የለንም፣ በአንድ በኩል አለም አቀፍ ህጎችን ማክበር፣ በሌላ በኩል ደግሞ አለም አቀፍ ህጎችን በማፍረስ እኛን ሊያጠቁ የሚሹ ሃገራትን ካካባቢያችን ማባረር ተግባርን መከተል ሊኖርብን ነው ማለት ነው::
    እነ እንግሊዝ አለምን አይገዙም፣ አለምን በሰነስርአቱ ስላላስተዳደሩ ይሄው ደሴት ሆነው ቀርተዋል፣ ግብፅና ሱዳንም የነሱ ኮሎኒ አይደሉም እና ስለ ኮሎኒያል ጊዜ ድርድሮችና ውሎች ባያደነቁሩን መልካም ይሆናል:: ኢትዮጵያ ደግሞ የመሪዎች ድህነት እየገጠማት ነው እንጂ ከማንም አገር የማያንስ የንጥረ ሃብትና ምጣኔ ሃብት Resources አላት፣ ግብጽ ከመርከብ ማሳለፍያ ወደብ (ስዊዝ ካናል) በስተቀር ይህ ነው የሚባል resource የላትም፣ ኢትዮጵያ ግን ከተራራዎችዋ ጀምሮ እስከ ሸለቆችዋ ተፈጥሮ ባርኮ የፈጠራት ሃገር ናት፣ የሚጎለው ያለው ይሄንን በስነስርአቱ የሚገነዘብና በተግባርም የሚያስተገብር ጭንቅላት ነው፣ እርስ በራስ ከመናከስ ይልቅ ያለንን ፖተንሻል ተገንዝበን አብረን መጠቀምንና ማደግን ማስቀደሙ ነው፣ ከዚህም በላይ ደግሞ ኢትዮጵያ ህገመንግስቷ ዘንዳ እንደ ተቀዳሚ ወንጀል ብላ ማስፈር ያለባት ጉዳይ፣ የውጭ ሃይሎች ተላላኪነትን ነው፣ በስመ “ነፃ አውጭነት” ከውጭ ሃይሎች ፍርፋሪን እየተቀበሉ በኢትዮጵያ ላይ የሚላላኩን ሁሉን፣ ከግለሰብ ጀምሮ እስከ ድርጅት በመላን ከፍተኛውን የህግ ቅጣት እንደምትፈርድ አስፍራ፣ ይሄንንም ደግሞ በተግባር ማዋል አለባት::
    በእንደዚህ ራሳችንን ለዘለቄታው ካስተካከልን ለራሳችን ሆነን ለሌሎችም እንተርፋለን እንጂ በማንም ስግብግብ blackmailed አንደረግምና፣ ሃየ ወዲ ዓዲ ኢድንኢድ ተሓቋቆፍ……………….!!!

  5. በ ግድባችን የተነሳ ሃገራችን ከፍተኛ አደጋ ላይ ትገኛለች። ለዚህም ምክንያቶቹ ሃገር፟_በቀል ባንዳዎች ናቸው። የ ግብጽን አላማ ለማሳካት እና ኢትያጵያን ለመበታተን የተዘጋጁ ቅጥረኞች በከፍተኛ እንቅስቃሴ ላይ እንዳሉ ግልፅ ነው። ሰሞኑን ግድቡን ለማፍረስ ሲንቀሳቀሱ የተያዙት ባንዳዎችን ተልዕኮ ስንገነዘብ አገራችን አሳሳቢ ሁኔታ ላይ እንዳለች እንገነዘባለን። ያ ሳያንስ ደግሞ የ ግድቡ ማስፈጸሚያ ባጄት ከ ሁለት እጥፍ በላይ አድጓል። ይህ ገንዘብ ከየት እንደሚገኝ ፈጣሪ ይወቀው። ባለፉት ጥቂት ቀናት የ አሜሪካው አምባሳደራችን በተለያዩ ምክንያቶች በ አሜሪካ የሚኖሩ ኢትዮጵያውያን ዕርዳታ ማዋጣት አይችሉም ብሎ ስሰማ አዝኛለሁ። በ ካናዳ ለ አምስት ቀናት ተካሂዶ የተገኘው ገንዘብ 60 000 ገደማ ብቻ ነበር። ግድቡ ሥራ ላይ ቢውልም ባንዳዎቹ ኢንፍራስትራክቸሩን ከማፍረስ ምን ያስቆማቸዋል? ተስፋ አስቆራጭ ነው። ምናልባት ግድቡን ትተን አገራችንን ከ ጥፋት እንታደግ ያሰኛል።

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.